Skip to main content
(716) 350-0600
24/7 Live Answering

How Insurance Payments Can Shrink a Verdict

Posted October 23, 2026 in Personal Injury

An injured person in New York can win a verdict and still see the final number come in lower than expected. One reason is a statute that lets the court reduce an award for payments the person already received from certain outside sources. Knowing how it works helps set realistic expectations before trial.

New York Lets Courts Reduce Awards for Certain Payments

Under CPLR 4545, in personal injury, property damage, and wrongful death actions that seek medical, custodial, or rehabilitation costs, lost earnings, or other economic loss, evidence is admissible to show that those costs were or will be paid by a collateral source. If the court finds that a cost has been or will be replaced or indemnified, it reduces the award by that amount.

The Court Makes the Deduction After the Verdict

The jury decides what the losses are, and the injured person can prove the full amount at trial. The deduction is made by the trial court after the verdict. That order of events means the jury hears the whole picture of what the injury cost, and the adjustment comes later.

Two Adjustments Soften the Reduction

The statute doesn’t simply subtract everything. The court also takes into account the premiums the injured person paid for those benefits in the two years before the action accrued, along with the projected future cost of maintaining the benefits. For future expenses, the court must find that the person is legally entitled to continue receiving the collateral source under a contract or other enforceable agreement.

Some Payments Are Not Treated as Collateral Sources

The statute carves out exceptions. Life insurance is not a collateral source, and neither are payments that carry a statutory right of reimbursement. Voluntary charitable contributions to an injured person are not counted either. Those exclusions can change the math in a given case. Whether a payment falls within an exception depends on the terms of the plan, so the paperwork from each payer deserves a close read.

Records That Matter Before Trial

Details about who paid what make a difference. Useful records include:

  • Health insurance statements showing amounts paid for treatment.
  • Notices of reimbursement rights or liens from payers.
  • Records of premiums paid during the two years before the claim arose.
  • Documents showing whether future benefits are guaranteed by contract.

Keeping these in order is part of what a Buffalo personal injury lawyer does when preparing a case for trial, so the court has an accurate figure to work with. Missing documents are easier to track down before trial than during it.

Proving What the Injury Cost

The deduction only applies to economic losses. Pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life are separate, and the evidence for them looks different. Jurors weigh more than bills, and proving pain and suffering means showing how the injury changed daily routines and relationships.

Economic losses need their own paper trail. Keeping receipts for claimable expenses from the start makes it easier to show what was spent and what insurance later covered.

Different Claims Raise Different Questions

Car crash claims bring in no-fault benefits, a separate system that pays certain expenses regardless of fault. Which expenses were already paid is often tied to no-fault insurance claims, so those records belong in the file.

Falls on someone else’s property involve their own proof. For a Buffalo slip and fall lawyer, the focus is what the owner knew about the hazard and whether the owner had a chance to fix it. When insurance pays part of the medical bills in those cases, the collateral source rule comes back into play.

The statute reaches wrongful death actions as well, so a Buffalo wrongful death lawyer tracks which payments could be treated as offsets. That tracking starts with the payer records described above.

How We Prepare Cases for Trial

At Hurwitz, Whitcher & Molloy, partner Michael J. Whitcher has been with our firm since 1992 and concentrates on workers’ compensation and personal injury. Our firm has more than 50 years of experience. We track every payment tied to a client’s treatment so that nothing about the damages surprises us after the verdict.

Thinking Ahead About the Final Number

A verdict is not always the amount that reaches the injured person, and a settlement discussion should account for that. An insurer may argue that part of the claimed losses is already covered, and the answer should be ready. Anyone hurt in an accident in the Buffalo area who is weighing a settlement against a trial can reach out to a Buffalo personal injury lawyer to review the payments already received and how the court may treat them.